Real estate transfer tax on the non-cash formation of a KG by transfer of shares

Dec 11, 2024
Tax

Real estate transfer tax again!

Extension of the chain of shareholdings in land-owning corporations within the temporal scope of application of Section 1 (2b) GrEStGFG Baden-Württemberg (judgment of 26.4.24 - 5 K 1696/23). 24 - 5 K 1696/23) confirms, as expected, tax liability in a case of a spin-off to absorb a land-owning GmbH into a KG that had recently been founded “itself.”

Under the legal situation until June 30, 2021, the transaction was (only) taxable pursuant to Section 1 III No. 3 GrEStG, but tax-exempt pursuant to Section 5 II GrEStG. This means that the “prevention of abuse” by Section 1 (2b) GrEStG once again proves to be less than accurate.‍

FC Nuremberg: no dispensation from reservation periods

The formation of the KG in kind is not comparable with the cases in which the BFH considers compliance with the reservation period of § 6a sentence 4 GrEStG to be dispensable. The obligation to make the contribution in kind is to be separated from its execution, even if the transfer of shares takes place immediately.

This is a continuation of what applies in the area of real estate transfers, because section 6a sentence 1 GrEStG only includes section 1 para. 1 no. 3 GrEStG in the privileged status, which is serious for partnerships because sole traders cannot outsource to them to form a new company (cf. section 152 UmwG). At the same time, the decision shows that the introduction of section 1 para. 2b GrEStG is poorly crafted.

This is because an acquisition transaction pursuant to § 1 para. 3 no. 3 GrEStG by a KG of the sole shareholder was and is tax-exempt pursuant to § 5 para. 2 GrEStG. The legal consequence that has occurred here has nothing, absolutely nothing, to do with the abuse-preventing objective of the 2021 real estate transfer tax reform!

Manuel Brühl

Das könnte Dir auch gefallen:

Jan 28, 2025
Tax
all
BFH enables tax-optimized management participation
Nov 5, 2024
Tax
all
Real estate transfer tax for share deals
Oct 2, 2024
Tax
all
Generosity in cases of § 7 para. 8 sentence 1 ErbStG
Sep 19, 2024
Tax
all
A ruling by the Munich tax court (3 K 2755/22 Erb) sheds exciting light on the interplay between inheritance tax and income tax
Sep 10, 2024
Tax
all
Payments for the redemption of a conditional usufruct of company shares are not taxable
Aug 29, 2024
Tax
all
According to the Hamburg tax court, the application of the exemption rules of Section 13b para. 1 no. 3 ErbStG is possible in the case of a disproportionate contribution
Aug 22, 2024
Tax
all
Effects of the ruling of the Munich Fiscal Court (4 K 1385/23) on the practice of real estate valuation
Jan 9, 2025
Tax
all
Decision with design potential: Land under construction does not constitute harmful administrative assets
Jan 14, 2025
Tax
all
No wages in the case of a gift transfer of company shares to secure company succession (BFH of November 20, 2024, VI R 21/22)
Dec 2, 2024
Tax
all
Procedural questions regarding the contribution of co-entrepreneurial shares pursuant to § 20 UmwstG
Jan 24, 2025
M&A
all
Vesting - Berlin Court of Appeal makes important decision for investors
Jan 24, 2025
Tax
all
Extended property reduction
Jan 15, 2025
Tax
all
Extended property reduction - Berlin-Brandenburg tax court - 8 K 8179/22 judgment of November 5, 2024
Jan 7, 2025
M&A
all
Sustainable M&A - legal aspects