Decision with design potential: Land under construction does not constitute harmful administrative assets

Jan 9, 2025
Tax

According to Section 13 (4) no. 1 ErbStG, land leased to third parties is considered harmful administrative assets and is generally not subject to inheritance and gift tax. But what about properties that are still under construction? It becomes particularly interesting if there is already an intention to let the property to third parties at a later date.

The Münster tax court (judgments of 14.11.2024 - 3 K 906/23 F & 3 K 908/23 F) has ruled: In such cases, there are no tax-damaging administrative assets. The key question: Are the requirements of Section 13b para. 4 no. 1 ErbStG met at the time of the gift?

According to the court, no - because at the time of the transfer, the property was not rented out to third parties but was under construction. The purpose of the law is clear: the tax relief for business assets is to be prevented if they would be classified as risk-free private asset management due to being rented out to third parties.

However, in the case of unused property, it remains unclear whether it will later be used for business purposes or rented out to third parties, and the strict cut-off date principle prevents possible future uses - whether due to the nature of the property or the purpose of the company - from being taken into account to the detriment of the taxpayer.

The court also made it clear that the choice of the transfer date is a free decision of the donor and the donee and does not constitute an inappropriate arrangement. Furthermore, the decision did not affect the complexity or effectiveness of the gift.

If the BFH confirms the decision on appeal, this will provide an exciting opportunity to avoid harmful administrative assets.

Tim Hoferichter

Das könnte Dir auch gefallen:

Jan 28, 2025
Tax
all
BFH enables tax-optimized management participation
Nov 5, 2024
Tax
all
Real estate transfer tax for share deals
Dec 11, 2024
Tax
all
Real estate transfer tax on the non-cash formation of a KG by transfer of shares
Oct 2, 2024
Tax
all
Generosity in cases of § 7 para. 8 sentence 1 ErbStG
Sep 19, 2024
Tax
all
A ruling by the Munich tax court (3 K 2755/22 Erb) sheds exciting light on the interplay between inheritance tax and income tax
Sep 10, 2024
Tax
all
Payments for the redemption of a conditional usufruct of company shares are not taxable
Aug 29, 2024
Tax
all
According to the Hamburg tax court, the application of the exemption rules of Section 13b para. 1 no. 3 ErbStG is possible in the case of a disproportionate contribution
Aug 22, 2024
Tax
all
Effects of the ruling of the Munich Fiscal Court (4 K 1385/23) on the practice of real estate valuation
Jan 14, 2025
Tax
all
No wages in the case of a gift transfer of company shares to secure company succession (BFH of November 20, 2024, VI R 21/22)
Dec 2, 2024
Tax
all
Procedural questions regarding the contribution of co-entrepreneurial shares pursuant to § 20 UmwstG
Jan 24, 2025
M&A
all
Vesting - Berlin Court of Appeal makes important decision for investors
Jan 24, 2025
Tax
all
Extended property reduction
Jan 15, 2025
Tax
all
Extended property reduction - Berlin-Brandenburg tax court - 8 K 8179/22 judgment of November 5, 2024
Jan 7, 2025
M&A
all
Sustainable M&A - legal aspects